DeLong Smackdown Watch: Hoisted from Comments
"In the Provinces" writes:
Grasping Reality with Both Hands: Economist Brad DeLong's Fair, Balanced, and Reality-Based Semi-Daily Journal: Theobald von Bethmann-Hollweg was a much nicer man than Dick Cheney, and his conscience bothered him a lot more about starting a criminal war of aggression than Dick Cheney's has.










This is one of the rare times in which I have to come to Brad's defense here. Dick Cheney may well have one eye on the center of his forehead, but he has not generated the human catastrophe on the scale that Kaiser Willy, Kaiser Franz Josef, Helmut von Moltke, and Bethmann-Hollweg did.
Cheney could fear no physical repercussions other than low-level terrorism against the US increasing and a mere few thousand American soldiers coming home in body bags. But the leaders of the Central Powers chose to invade their Iraq and Afghanistan knowing full well that an equally powerful enemy coalitio was willing to oppose them militarily. If the Austro-German invasion of Serbia and Belgium had generated no more repercussions than did the US invasion of Iraq, Bethmann-Hollweg would have had a much easier time living with his conscience.
Posted by: andres | January 08, 2008 at 04:26 PM
> Dick Cheney may well have one eye on the center of
> his forehead, but he has not generated the human
> catastrophe on the scale that Kaiser Willy, Kaiser
> Franz Josef, Helmut von Moltke, and Bethmann-Hollweg did.
Not that is so immediately apparent, no. But the results aren't in yet and won't be for 50, possibly 100 years. Terminating all progress on the energy and climate issues and roiling the Middle East into, well, an angry beehive (thanks PNAC) may have long-run consequences even worse than The Great War[1].
In any case Brad is to be thanked for these two threads. The effect of 1880-1910 Germany on US history (and the rest of the world too) is underappreciated in my opinion.
Cranky
[1] Now, if you think that there is a direct link between the trenches and training barracks of the war and the Spanish influenza epidemic, then that is another story.
Posted by: Cranky Observer | January 08, 2008 at 07:14 PM