John Holbo: The Year of the MOOC?

« I Understand That We Ought to Cut David Gelernter Some Slack... | Main | Liveblogging World War II: November 9, 1942 »

November 09, 2012

John Holbo: The Year of the MOOC?

John Holbo:

The Year of the MOOC?: I ought at least to link to the NY Times piece on MOOCS - Massive Open Online Courses…. Clay Shirky asked in comments to my last post what I thought about this stuff and I said I was ignorant. Which I am. That said, I’m a big believer that this stuff will somehow work out for the best. The upside is just too way up…. I’ve always availed myself of webcast options whenever possible – especially when I was teaching a 500+ student intro module. Webcast kills live theater attendance but it’s just so damn convenient for students to be able to download an MP3 of the lecture to go with their copy of the PPT…. The book – the old-fashioned paper book – was the original MOOC app. Then again, no. A book is not a course. A library is not a university. And so a library of online learning resources is not an online university. MOOC’s are going to help people who are self-motivated and already know how to learn. They will help those who can already help themselves….

[T]his still requires the students to be mature and self-motivated, as learners, to start with. This is such a huge number of people – especially globally – that it’s great news, all in all. But it leaves a lot of people behind – students better served by a more traditional college experience…. [I]t’s paradoxical to say that MOOC’s are for advanced students, whereas meatspace college is more remedial, in a disciplinary sort of way. (Poor kid, he has to go to Harvard because he’s not ready for Coursera!)… In a world of MOOC’s, traditional college is ambiguous between remedial learning for those who haven’t yet learned how to learn, and a premium personal coaching service…. Oh, and credentialing…

J. Bradford DeLong on November 09, 2012 at 03:25 AM in Streams: Economics | Permalink

Comments

Contribute to Funding Grasping Reality

------------------------------

Search

Definitely Worth Reading...

Highlighted

Probably Worth Reading...

Spotlight Posts

Brookings Productivity Puzzle Panel: VIdeo
_[The Productivity Puzzle][]_: >On September 9, 2016 the Initiative on Business and Public Policy and the Hutchins Center on Fiscal and Monetary Policy at Brookings hosted a forum on the policy implications of the growth slowdown. [The Productivity Puzzle]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dojtWYrjnbc&feature=youtu.be&ab_channel=BrookingsInstitution
The Long-Run Economic Trend Is Our Friend: No Longer so Fresh at Project Syndicate
**[Over at Project Syndicate][1]: The Long-Run Economic Trend is Our Friend** These are days of grave disappointment at the state of the world. Sinister forces of fanatic religion-linked murder that we thought had been largely scotched by 1750 are back. They have been joined by and are reinforcing forces of...
Economists for Trump!
They are the usual suspects--people who have been 100% wrong since at least 2007, and yet lack any intellectual curiosity to try to rethink their view of the world and so understand why things have developed differently than they had thought they would: Eugene Fama in the lead, with June...
Night Thoughts on Dynamic Scoring: Hoisted from a Year Ago
****: [Night Thoughts on Dynamic Scoring](http://www.bradford-delong.com/2015/09/night-thoughts-on-dynamic-scoring.html): **Live from DuPont Circle:** Last Thursday two of the smartest participants at last Friday's Brookings Panel on Economic Activity conference--Martin Feldstein and Glenn Hubbard--claimed marvelous things from the enactment of JEB!'s proposed tax cuts and his regulatory reform program. They claimed: * that it...
The Clones of Jim Tobin vs. the Gravitational Pull of Chicago: A Paul Krugman Production...
The highly-esteemed **Mark Thoma** sends us to **Paul Krugman**. In praise of real science: "Some people... always ask, 'Is this the evidence talking, or my preconceptions?' And you want to be one of those people...". Paul's most aggressive claim is that our economics profession in 2007 would have done a...
Musings on "Just Deserts" and the Opening of Plato's Republic
**Musings on "Just Deserts" and the Opening of [Plato's Republic][]:** Greg Mankiw [Defending the 1%][] proposes what he calls the "just deserts" theory of social justice: *What you have gained and hold by playing by the economic rules is yours: social justice consists in not cheating or injuring people, and...
Files Related to the Hutchins-Brookings Productivity Festival
**UPDATE:** Relatively happy now: _[Brookings Productivity Festival: DeLong Edited Transcript (September 9, 2016)][]_ [Brookings Productivity Festival: DeLong Edited Transcript (September 9, 2016)]: http://www.bradford-delong.com/2016/09/brookings-productivity-festival-delong-edited-transcript-september-9-2016.html ---- I am not happy with any of the presentations/notes I prepared for this conference. But, for what it's worth, here is the organizers' precis, and my...
Brookings Productivity Festival: DeLong Edited Transcript (September 9, 2016)
_[The Productivity Puzzle: How Can We Speed Up the Growth of the Economy?][]_ [The Productivity Puzzle: How Can We Speed Up the Growth of the Economy?]: https://www.brookings.edu/events/the-productivity-puzzle-how-can-we-speed-up-the-growth-of-the-economy/ ---- First, I need to stop flashing to the dystopian future which Bronwyn here has made me imagine. It is one in which...
Talking Points for Fox News Business This Afternoon (September 15, 2016: 2 PM)...
**(1) How well does HRC do her job, really?** * Consensus judgment well-expressed by Donald Trump: * “she really works hard, and I think she does a good job...” * “I know Hillary and I think she’d make a great president...” * “smart, tough and a very nice person...” *...
Very Brief Musings on Democracy
Cf.: **Christopher H. Achen and Larry M. Bartels**: _[Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government][]_ [Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government]: http://amzn.to/2cxeQfg (Christopher H. Achen and Larry M. Bartels (2016): _Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government_ (Princeton: Princeton University...
The New York TImes and John F. Burns Suppressing the News That's Fit to Print: Hoisted from the Archives
The memory of man runneth not to the day that I could trust that with reasonable probability anything new in the _New York Times_ would be true: [Some of the News That's Fit to Print (Why Oh Why Can't We Have a Better Press Corps?)](http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2006/01/some_of_the_new.html) (January 29, 2006): In Slate,...
The Wayback Machine: From Ten Years Ago: August 31-September 13, 2006
* **2006-09-13**: _[Un-Atlantic Economic History][]_: It is a fair criticism that we Berkeley Economics people think Economic History is Atlantic Economic History, and overwhelmingly North Atlantic Economic History. Well, now I have a new course's worth of readings to compile--and I know I will have read only an appallingly small...
Monday Smackdown: Sam Tanenhaus Department
Sam Tanenhaus--who has a substantial history of whitewashing wingnuts--calls for reporters to... not do their jobs. They should not cover what Donald Trump says and does. They should not cover what Trump said and did. Why not? Out of fear of some political payback or electoral backlash: MSM is making...
Weekend Reading: Paul Krugman (2011): Mr. Keynes and the Moderns
**Paul Krugman** (2011): _[Mr Keynes and the Moderns][]_: >It’s a great honour to be asked to give this talk, especially because I’m arguably not qualified to do so.[1][] I am, after all, not a Keynes scholar, nor any kind of serious intellectual historian. Nor have I spent most of my...
911: Never Forget
As Benjamin Franklin said: "It is a rising, not a setting sun." And one more thing we should never forget: _[Presidential Daily Brief: August 6, 2001][]_: Plus: **Scott Erik Kaufman**: [What we should never forget on 9/11](http://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2015/09/what-we-should-never-forget-on-911): Shared with permission from Siva Vaidhyanathan... [Presidential Daily Brief: August 6, 2001]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike_in_US
Slow Growth in Productivity: What Do We Know About "Why?" and "What Is To Be Done?"—Long
J. Bradford DeLong :: U.C. Berkeley, NBER, and WCEG :: 2016-09-09 :: | _[The productivity puzzle: How can we speed up the growth of the economy?][]_ [The productivity puzzle: How can we speed up the growth of the economy?]: https://www.brookings.edu/events/the-productivity-puzzle-how-can-we-speed-up-the-growth-of-the-economy/ ---- ##Slow Growth in Productivity: What Do We Know About...
Slow Growth in Productivity: Can Anything Be Done?
J. Bradford DeLong :: U.C. Berkeley, NBER, and WCEG :: 2016-09-09 :: ---- ##Slow Growth in Productivity: Can Anything Be Done? J. Bradford DeLong :: U.C. Berkeley, NBER, and WCEG :: 2016-09-09 :: **What Are We Talking About Here?:** * Perceived poor performance of the American economy. * Measurement issues...
Follow-Up Questions on the Philosophy of Probability: Hoisted from the Archives
Every once in a while I think I really ought to think some more about Knightian uncertainty. And I invariably bounce off into something like this... ****: [Tuesday Virtual Office Hours: Follow-Up Questions on the Philosophy of Probability: Live from Cafe Milano CCXXXIII: August 5, 2014](http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2014/08/tuesday-virtual-office-hours-follow-up-questions-on-the-philosophy-of-probability.html): (Roughly) the way [Cosma...
Musings on Productivity
**Musings on Productivity (Triggered by (but not to be presented at) the September 8-9, 2016 Hutchins Center Brookings Institution Productivity Festival)** J. Bradford DeLong :: U.C. Berkeley, NBER, and WCEG :: 2016-09-07 |
Brookings Productivity Festival on Friday Morning...
**[Over at Equitable Growth][1]**: The current discussion of "slow growth in measured productivity" here in the U.S. seems to suffer from a great deal of confusion. **[Read MOAR Over at Equitable Growth][1]** [1]: http://equitablegrowth.org/?p=29456 From my perspective, there are six things going on: 1. Since the 1920s, the rise of...