Andrew Delbanco: The Two Faces of American Education: Noted
Noted for Your Morning Procrastination for October 7, 2013

Diane Coyle: The science of political economy: Noted

Diane Coyle: The science of political economy:

My thanks to Professor Ian Preston of University College London for the earliest definition (in England) of the subject of economics--it’s from the 1827  Statement by the Council of the University of London Explanatory of the Nature and Objects of the Institution:

The object of the science of Political Economy is to ascertain the laws which regulate the production, distribution and consumption of wealth, or the outward things obtained by labour, and needed or desired by man. It is now too justly valued to require any other remark, than the occasional difficulty of applying its principles, and the differences of opinion to which that difficulty has given rise, form new reasons for the diligent cultivation of a science which is so indispensable to the well-being of communities, and of which, as it depends wholly on facts, all the perplexities must finally be removed by accurate observation and precise language.

The wonderfully Victorian optimism contrasts with Nassim Taleb’s disdain for economists, which bellows from every other page of Antifragile. I’m rather enjoying it so far, but he has a very low opinion of economists, especially those of us who are Harvard-trained (he always refers to it as ‘Stalin-Harvard’). He has it in for nail polish too, and as I occasionally wear it, that’s another strike against me. However, he does like Ariel Rubinstein’s Economic Fables, an excellent book (and winner of the 2012 Enlightened Economist Prize).

I met Taleb once--it was in late 2001 at the launch in London of my book Paradoxes of Prosperity, around the same time as Fooled by Randomness was published and about to make him massively famous. He had shaved his beard and was travelling as ‘Nicholas’ not ‘Nassim’ at the time, I recall him telling me. He was charming and polite, far from the aggressive and slightly deranged--although hugely interesting--persona that comes across in his books. The Black Swan and Fooled by Randomness are both great reads containing much sense, so I’m looking forward to the rest of Antifragile. And I don’t believe economics to be wholly incompatible with Taleb’s worldview--just look at that 1827 definition.